Presbyters Uniwersytet Warszawski
ID
ER 266
Canon 27 of the Council of Carthage (North Africa, 419 AD) makes the expulsion from the holy orders for grave crimes definitive and prohibits ordaining the rebaptized.
Canon 27
 
Item confirmatum est: vt si quando presbyteri uel diaconi in aliqua grauiore culpa conuicti fuerint, qua eos a ministerio necesse sit remouere, non eis manus uel tamquam paenitentibus uel tamquam fidelibus laicis imponatur.
Neque permittendum ut rebaptizati ad clericatus gradum promoueantur.
 
(ed. Munier 1974: 109)
Canon 27
 
This also was confirmed: if presbyters or deacons were convicted of any of the more grave crimes, so that it was necessary to remove them from the ministry, then hands shall not be laid upon them as upon penitents or faithful laymen.
Neither should it be permitted that the rebaptized are promoted to the clerical grade.
 
(trans. S. Adamiak)
 
 
 

Discussion:

The canon is more complicated that it may seem from a perfunctory analysis which would suggest that it simply prohibits the readmission into the clergy of those for whom guilt of 'more grave crimes' was proved. I am not sure what exactly the imposition of hands means here. If it is really the sign of ordination, then why the distinction between the penitents and the faithful lay people? Is it a sign of penance and reconciliation, which is declined to presbyters and deacons, who seem to be considered as the worst offenders among the clergy; did the bishops , gathered at the council, not consider bishops as able to commit such trespasses?
The second phrase seems to to target the ex-Donatists, not the possibilty that a cleric deprived of his office would seek the readmittance in the clergy by the way of repeating the baptism.  Such meaning is suggested by some translations (H. Percival, G. Pilara), but it would be a rather outrageous practice for the 5th century Catholic Church in Africa, in the midst of the controversy with the Donatists. The 'rebaptizati' from this phrase are not referred to by any specific pronoun, and my interpretation is strengthened by the Italian textual tradition, in which this canon is divided into two separate ones: 'On the lapsed presbyters' and 'On the rebaptized'.

Place of event:

Region
  • Latin North Africa
City
  • Carthage

About the source:

Title: Canones in causa Apiarii
Origin: Carthage (Latin North Africa)
Denomination: Catholic/Nicene/Chalcedonian
Apiarius, a presbyter of Sicca Veneria in North Africa, was excommunicated for some unspecified crimes by his bishop, Urbanus. In 418 he appealed directly to Pope Zosimus, who sent legates to Africa to assess the charges. The council of African bishops gathered in Carthage in May 419 to address the question. On the 25 May they approved several disciplinary canons, mainly repeated from previous councils, which are known collectively in scholarly literature as `Canones in causa Apiarii`. They were also sometimes transmitted as the part of the `Codex Apiarii causae`, together with other acts of the council of 419.
We follow the edition of Munier, who followed Turner, who established the text according to three codices: Vindobonensis 2141, fol. 106, Monacensis (olim Frisingensis), fol. 64`, and Wirceburgensis Univ. mp. th. f. 146, fol. 66. We ignore the later textual traditions, namely Italian collections (which were the basis of the edition of the brothers Ballerini in PL 56), and the redaction of Dionysius Exiguus; both of them have been included in the Corpus Christianorum edition, and they contain only minor changes, which we ignore, with the exception of two canons not transmitted in the first recension.
Edition:
C. Munier ed., Concilia Africae a. 345-a. 525, Corpus Christianorum. Series Latina 149, Turnhoult 1974, 79-165.  
 
Bibliography:
J. Gaudemet, Les Sources du droit de l'Église en Occident du IIe au VIIe siècle, Paris, 1985.
C.H. Turner, Ecclesiae occidentalis monumenta iuris antiquissima, vol. 1-2, Oxford 1889-1939.

Categories:

Religious grouping (other than Catholic/Nicene/Chalcedonian) - Donatist
    Change of denomination
      Described by a title - Presbyter/πρεσβύτερος
        Impediments or requisits for the office - Improper/Immoral behaviour
          Act of ordination
            Ritual activity - Imposition of hands
              Public law - Ecclesiastical
                Further ecclesiastical career - Lay status
                  Administration of justice - Ecclesiastical
                    Administration of justice - Demotion
                      Please quote this record referring to its author, database name, number, and, if possible, stable URL: S. Adamiak, Presbyters in the Late Antique West, ER266, http://www.presbytersproject.ihuw.pl/index.php?id=6&SourceID=266